Missed an RMD? 25% tax, 10% if you correct it in time

Rules

Missing a $10,000 RMD costs $2,500 in excise tax, or $1,000 if the amount is taken and the tax reported within the correction window; the IRS can also waive it for a reasonable error.

Understanding the Excise Tax Structure

The excise tax applies to any shortfall in your required minimum distribution. As the key figures show, the standard penalty is higher than the corrected amount. This difference reflects the incentive to fix errors quickly. The table below illustrates how the tax scales with the shortfall size. You calculate the tax based on the difference between what you withdrew and what was required. The rate depends entirely on when you act. If you correct the error within the allowed window, the tax burden decreases significantly. This structure encourages prompt compliance without requiring complex calculations. Use the RMD calculator to determine your specific shortfall amount before applying these rates.

Excise tax on the amount not withdrawn in time
Shortfall ($)Tax at 25% ($)Tax at 10% ($)
1,000250100
5,0001,250500
10,0002,5001,000
25,0006,2502,500

The Correction Window Rules

To qualify for the lower tax rate, you must take specific actions within a defined timeframe. First, withdraw the missed amount. Second, file the necessary tax return reflecting this correction. The window closes at the earliest of three events: receiving a deficiency notice, the assessment of tax, or the end of the second year following the year the distribution was due. Missing this deadline means paying the higher rate. The table above confirms that timely action reduces the cost. These deadlines are strict. Plan your withdrawals and filings early to ensure you meet the cutoff. The rules apply from the current tax year onward.

Seeking a Waiver for Reasonable Errors

The IRS may waive the excise tax if you can demonstrate a reasonable cause for the shortfall. This process requires filing the appropriate form with a clear explanation. A reasonable cause might include a banking error or a misunderstanding of the rules. The waiver is not automatic. You must provide evidence supporting your claim. If granted, the waiver eliminates the tax liability entirely. If denied, you pay the applicable rate based on your correction timing. Review the methodology to understand how these calculations are applied in practice. Always keep records of your communications with financial institutions to support your case.

Questions

How is the excise tax calculated?

The tax is calculated as a percentage of the shortfall amount. The standard rate applies if you miss the correction deadline. A lower rate applies if you correct the error within the specified window.

When does the correction window close?

The window ends at the earliest of three dates: the date of a deficiency notice, the date of tax assessment, or the end of the second year after the year the distribution was due.

Can I get a waiver for missing an RMD?

Yes, if you have a reasonable cause. You must file the relevant form with an explanation. The IRS reviews the reason and decides whether to grant the waiver.

Every figure on this page is computed by code from the IRS Uniform Lifetime and Single Life tables (Publication 590-B and 26 CFR 1.401(a)(9)-9). See the methodology.

Updated: